Misinformation Impact

A few years back, a popular topic of conversation at my workplace was astrology. Several of my coworkers were passionate about the subject. One often mentioned that her aunt was a psychic and that gifts ran in her family. She was the most informed in the group.

I am sure astrology was brought up several times every week. Although this information was floating about our headsets frequently, literally directly into my ear, it didn’t stick with me.

While I unfortunately did not retain anything from the topic, as there were far too many things said in passing to recall, I do remember some observations upon reflection. I realized it can become a topic that produces strange results, because many people in the group did not feel just neutrally toward the subject.

Once two people found they had conflicting beliefs, one of three things would happen. I have witnessed 1. Disconnect 2. Confusion 3. Tension. If worked through, both viewpoints have the opportunity to merge into something new.

Disconnect occurs when the subject is quickly changed, for example if Sophia thought Scorpio’s were X when in the astrological world it is agreed upon they are Y. Confusion takes place when my coworkers were unable to check their phones while busy, but couldn’t recall which element was assigned to a specific zodiac. Tension is present when new information is being shared that someone else has not heard of before.

When it comes to sharing information, spreading misinformation can be an unfortunate side effect. This may occur when information is shared too soon before being properly verified. Similarly, if an individual does not have a full and well rounded view about a subject, they may not realize something they hold true is actually false. People don’t mean to spread incorrect information.

Just as I suspected.. After some searching I found this article that supports this view.

March 17 2021: Scientific American hosts an article titled Most People Don’t Actively Seek to Share Fake News by David Rand in which he states that research shows, “…over 80 percent of respondents felt that it’s very important to only share accurate content online..”.

Individuals share information because they find it important in some way. As some people will pass along media that happens to be in fact misinformation.

For example, a discussion about there being a 13th zodiac sign is brought up time and time again, like clockwork.

I happened upon the information of a new zodiac and I brought it up to my coworkers. I wasn’t yet that informed on the subject and wanted to learn more. They didn’t know about it either and it caused some of the aforementioned confusion. Ever since, I try to stay informed before speaking on something.

July 26, 2020: Dictionary.com What Is Ophiuchus And Is It Really Part Of The Zodiac? states, “Standard astrological zodiacs do not include Ophiuchus” and “Its addition to the zodiac was first suggested by astrologist Stephen Schmidt in 1970 and it was proposed again in 1995,” which goes to show this is not new information – but has been circulating since before the internet. It’s on the level of misinformation as it has been confirmed there is not a new zodiac, yet there has been confusion about the topic for years.

8/22/2023 : 24-Hour Media Diet

On August 22nd, 2023 I recorded my online habits for the day. The purpose of this 24-Hour Media Diet assignment for course MCO427 is to locate misinformation across natural sources of media over the course of a typical day. I set out to find these posts in the wild, through my phone. On a Monday.

10:00am – I rise and promptly hit snooze. I notice that my insurance company has emailed me while I have been sleeping.

10:15am – As I sit down to eat breakfast, I unsubscribe from receiving further insurance marketing emails. They are sorry to see me unsubscribe. I delete the most recently sent email regarding how to achieve my best personal health. I don’t doubt my insurance company but I also do not take unsolicited health advice from advertisements.

Sanrio has also emailed me about a collaboration with Bumkins, which is not relevant to my interests – but is based in Phoenix! I click the link anyway. The advertisement link leads to the kids clothing & shoes section of the site.

11am – 4pm – While at work, I am surrounded by advertisements for drinks and Spotify playlists play in the background. My phone sits patiently in my bag, waiting to be used.

5:15pm – State Farm makes an attempt at being relatable via Snapchat advertisement during dinner. The ad displays a woman swinging a cloth napkin above her head while at a dining table, with the caption “TFW you get affordable insurance.”

This statement is not valid in my personal experience. The company has both called and emailed me several times with rates that do not match up to others on the market and is outside of my budget.

As my intent was to view stories, the advertisement appearing within minutes of launching Snapchat caused me to promptly close it.

5:30pm – With an interest in home repair, I watch a YouTube short about restoring the tile of a bathroom. @TheYorks channel is dedicated to DIY home restoration and I trust their judgement. To do my due diligence, however, I located a similar impregnator sealer used in the video and verified the reviews on the Home Depot website. It appears this is an excellent product.

5:45pm – As I was finishing dinner, a YouTube short of how to take lemonade to the next level surfaced. Online, Jordan Howlett is known for producing extremely useful or fun facts about life. I found this recipe all over the internet to verify it’s good. There is no misinformation here.

7:00pm – For background noise, I listen to the channel @HigherMind9 of Bashar Channeling session, where it is said that an extraterrestrial being is being channeled through a human host. At the 15:12 mark of the video, it is said that a space craft is docked, “…above Bell Rock in your Sedona area.”

As I don’t know quite how to feel about this, I completed a little research to discover this article discussing an alternative perspective. On Sedona Red Rock News, Andrew Pardiac discusses another reason why this specific mountain feels energetically different in the area. The article states no scientific evidence supporting vortexes in the area.

8:00pm – Giving Snapchat another chance, I see an ad for Kiehl’s Truly targeted acne-clearing solution. After a quick Google search, I find the company truly has been around since 1851 according to the National Library of Medicine.

Yahoo News found this product to be one of the first of its kind. The site itself gives the product a 4.4 rating that also carries on over at Sephora, so it checks out.

9:30pm – Before logging off for the night, I browse Reddit and happen upon an energy drink promotion that sounds way too good to be true. Buy two Rockstar Energy drinks and get your money back? A very long bunny trail and even deeper rabbit hole finally led me to the terms and conditions where I validated this to be an official promotion.

I have come to realize that my bubble on the internet is very small. Prior to this assignment, I believed I had many sources of information coming to me to receive a well rounded idea of what is current online. Now, I understand that I am only viewing a very small fraction of media – so small and personalized that I barley even have a shot at seeing misinformation because of my interests.

To keep peace of mind, I typically avoid polarizing topics on the internet. I know this course will provide valuable insight on how to protect myself from misinformation when broadening my interests online.